
Sojourn Solutions partners with the Mortgage Bankers Association on an email marketing redesign that delivered a 24% increase in click-to-open rates
We are pleased to share the results of a project we are particularly proud of: a comprehensive email marketing redesign for the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA), where Sojourn Solutions served as the consulting partner alongside MBA's marketing and design teams.
The project spanned nine months from planning through launch, with departmental rollouts beginning in October 2025. It refreshed the design, structure and content approach across MBA's corporate and partner-group email communications, and the performance results speak for themselves.
The starting point
Email is MBA's most important marketing channel. It accounts for 46% of online purchases, making it the single largest driver of digital revenue ahead of direct traffic, organic search and every other channel combined. Open rates were already strong, running at 12% against an Eloqua Financial Services industry benchmark of 10.3%. But the click-to-open rate told a different story. At 7.4%, it sat well below the industry benchmark of 11.3%. People were opening MBA's emails. They were not clicking through.
That gap between opens and clicks became the central focus of the project. The question was not how to get more people to open emails. It was how to get the people who were already opening them to take the next step.
What the audit found
Sojourn Solutions conducted an email marketing audit that identified several structural factors working against click-through performance.
MBA's emails were image-heavy at a time when approximately 43% of email recipients have images blocked by default, particularly in Outlook, which is the dominant email client in MBA's B2B audience. When images were blocked, recipients saw large empty spaces before reaching any copy or calls to action. The calls to action themselves were often embedded within those images, meaning that in a blocked-image environment the primary path to the website disappeared entirely.
The emails were also long, which increased the risk of clipping in email clients that truncate messages past a certain length. And with the average time spent reading a marketing email sitting at around 12 seconds, the volume of content in each email was competing against how recipients actually consume them. By the time a reader scrolled past the header image and introductory copy to find the call to action, their 12 seconds were often already spent.
The strategy that emerged from the audit repositioned email as a pathway to the website rather than a destination in itself. The guiding principle was straightforward: email is a stepping stone, not the arrival point. Instead of trying to tell the full story inside the email, the redesigned approach would give recipients enough to understand the value and make it easy to click through for the rest.
The audit also recommended cleaning inactive contacts from the email database and increasing the use of multistep campaigns for action-based segmentation, both of which would support the design changes with better targeting over time.
What changed in the design
The redesign touched every layer of the email experience, from the header through to the footer.
The most visible change was the shift from image-led to message-led layouts. The previous emails opened with large banner graphics that carried the headline, event branding and key dates as part of the image. The new designs replaced this with a compact logo header followed immediately by the headline and calls to action as live text and HTML-based buttons. This meant the core message and the path to the website were visible the moment a recipient opened the email, even when images were blocked. It also significantly reduced the header area, getting readers to the substance faster.
Copy was reduced to a target range of 50 to 125 words per email. Rather than repeating everything available on the website, the new approach focused on programme highlights and the most relevant benefits, giving recipients a reason to click rather than a reason to stop reading. The copy provided enough context to understand the value without making the email itself the destination.
The team moved to a standard 600-pixel email width, aligning with modern email design practices and improving readability on both desktop and mobile. Body copy sizing and line spacing were updated to meet current accessibility standards. The overall effect was emails that were easier to scan, a significant improvement for an audience that spends an average of 12 seconds per message.
HTML-based buttons replaced image-based ones throughout, ensuring calls to action remained visible and functional regardless of image-blocking settings. The buttons were styled with rounded edges and brand-aligned colours, giving them a clean, modern appearance while maintaining consistency across different programmes. Supporting imagery moved below the fold, serving as brand reinforcement rather than occupying the prime real estate above the scroll.
At the same time, the redesign preserved the distinct identities of MBA's various programmes and partner groups. Each group retained its established brand colours and value statements within a consistent structural framework, creating a cohesive email experience that could flex across MBA's diverse range of communications. Whether it was the Annual Convention, mPowering You, the Accounting and Financial Management Conference or any of MBA's other programmes, the new design system gave each event its own visual identity while maintaining the structural consistency that supports performance.
The footer was also refined, with a lighter background colour and smaller logo and social icons that remained readable without competing for attention with the content above.
The results
Performance comparisons between April to December 2025 and January to September 2026 showed measurable improvement across the metrics that mattered most.
The average unique open rate increased by 1.4 percentage points. More significantly, the average click-to-open rate also increased by 1.4 percentage points, representing an approximately 24% relative increase from the pre-redesign baseline. That is exactly the outcome the project was designed to deliver: more of the people who open MBA's emails are now clicking through to the website.
The impact was visible at the individual campaign level as well. Across the top five highest-performing emails for MBA's Annual Convention, click-to-open rates in 2026 ranged from 10.8% to 18.7%, compared with 5.2% to 10.7% for the top five in 2025. The strongest-performing convention email in 2026 nearly doubled the click-to-open rate of the strongest in 2025.
These gains came from design and content changes, not from a larger send volume or a new platform. The same audience, the same marketing automation platform and the same team produced measurably better results by rethinking how the emails were structured and what they asked recipients to do.
A cross-functional effort
This was a genuinely collaborative project. MBA's marketing team, led by Alicia Roundy and Denise Royer, worked alongside art direction from Mark Jelfo and Garrett Cruce, design from Christopher Odum and consulting support from Sojourn Solutions. The result reflects what happens when strategy, design and operational expertise are aligned around a clear objective.
We are proud to have been part of a project that demonstrates what thoughtful, data-informed email marketing can achieve. The redesign did not require a new platform or a larger budget. It required a sharper understanding of how recipients actually interact with email, and the discipline to design for that reality rather than for how we wish people read.
For organisations looking at their own email performance, the MBA project is a reminder that the gap between opens and clicks is often a design and content problem, not an audience problem. The people are paying attention. The question is whether the email makes it easy enough for them to act.










